Skip to content


December 29, 2015

I got a little bogged down in the Temeraire novels after the first five, and so I didn’t rush to read Naomi Novik’s new fantasy novel Uprooted as soon as it came out. Eleanor gave it to me for Christmas, and I started reading it late one afternoon, paused to go watch the new Star Wars movie again, and finished it the next morning. It’s the kind of book I don’t necessarily want to read all in one sitting, because I like having a wonderful world in my head and wondering how it’s all going to come out.

Except that she’s a witch, I identified with the heroine of Uprooted, Agnieszka, because she attracts dirt like I do. My mother used to shake her head and say sadly, “Jeannie, dirt just falls on you.” She tells stories about dressing my younger brother and my cousin on holidays, and then dressing me last, hoping that there would be some clean places left by the time we got where we were going. Similarly, Agnieszka says:
“my mother despaired of me by the time I was twelve and let me run around in castoffs from my older brothers, except for feast days, when I was obliged to change only twenty minutes before we left the house, and then sit on the bench before our door until we walked to church. It was still even odds whether I’d make it to the village green without catching on some branch, or spattering myself with mud.”

The description of Agnieszka’s teacher trying to get her to do magic the right way almost brought tears to my eyes, so much did it remind me of the few times my mother tried to teach me to cook: “he tried to teach me as best he could, and to advise me in my blundering through….it offended his sense of the proper order of things that my slapdash workings did work, and he scowled as much when I was doing well as when I had made some evident mistake….How is that even working? he burst out, as he sometimes did when pressed past his limits by the obvious dreadfulness of my magic.”

Unlike me and my mother, however, Agnieszka and her teacher—the Dragon, as she first calls him, or Sarkan, as she comes to know him—learn to work together, her improvising and him providing the precision that makes their combined magic powerful.

The book is quite intricately plotted, with the history of Agnieszka’s village, the defenders of her kingdom, the places she played as a child and her best friend from childhood all acquiring importance as the story unfolds. It is a story within a previous story, too, which adds to the significance of the childhood friend’s, Kasia’s, observation that
“strange things always happened to you. You’d go into the forest and come back with fruit out of season, or flowers no one else had ever seen. When we were little, you always used to tell me stories the pines told you, until one day your brother sneered at you for playing make-believe, and you stopped. Even the way your clothes were always such a mess—you couldn’t get so dirty if you tried, and I knew you weren’t trying, you were never trying. I saw a branch reach out and snag your skirt once, really just reach out—“

Agnieszka looks through the books in the Dragon’s library and finds one that looks like a journal with spells that are more like lists of ingredients and suit her better than the elaborate and exact ones he has been trying to teach her. She finds out that the journal was written by “Jaga” (who turns out to be a Baba Yaga figure, although that is entirely outside the world of this story).

Some of the best parts are when Agnieszka finds out the actual facts behind the epic stories she has heard:
“That was when I realized that I already knew the story. I had heard it sung. Ludmila and the Enchanter, only in the song, the brave countess disguised herself as an old peasant woman and cooked and cleaned for the wizard who had stolen her husband’s heart, until she found it in his house locked inside a box, and she stole it back and saved him. My eyes prickled with hot tears. No one was enchanted beyond saving in the songs. The hero always saved them. There was no ugly moment in a dark cellar where the countess wept and cried out protest while three wizards put the count to death, and then made court politics out of it.”

A part I particularly liked was when Sarkan pulled out a book and Agnieszka wouldn’t touch it, causing him to say “yes, I know….It’s a necromantic text; it’s hideous.”

Oh, and the title–it keeps getting more and more relevant.

There is so much to like about this book that I don’t want to tell you much more about it and spoil your fun–the fun is immersing yourself in the world and letting it take you where it will, trusting that your heroine will choose the right path and you’ll be glad you followed her story to its magnificently happy end.

12 Comments leave one →
  1. December 29, 2015 2:41 pm

    I’m laughing at the necromancy line 😀 I really enjoyed this too. Such a wonderful world to step into.

    • December 30, 2015 7:02 pm

      It is! The necromancy line was just a personal little bonus for me.

  2. December 29, 2015 2:58 pm

    I heard so many good things about this book I bought myself a copy back at the beginning of summer planning to read it then. I even bought a copy for a friend’s birthday. She read it and loved it, I still haven’t managed to read it yet! The book is on my 2016 TBR pile and by golly, I will read it!

  3. December 29, 2015 8:10 pm

    I was bored to tears by the Temeraire novels, so have resisted this…but mayyyybe you have changed my mind?

    • December 30, 2015 7:01 pm

      I can’t imagine you being bored by this one, although I’m surprised to hear that you didn’t love the first Temeraire book–maybe the mere idea of a dragon carries me further than it does you.

  4. December 29, 2015 9:39 pm

    This book was one of my highlights of the year – reading this makes me want to go back and read it again. You know, I did think “necromancy! it never pays!” when Sarkan said that…

  5. December 30, 2015 12:15 pm

    This isn’t an author I know but I’m looking for a new fantasy writer that my godson and I can share. Where do we start?

    • December 30, 2015 6:58 pm

      I would start with this one, and then maybe try Holly Black’s The Darkest Part of the Forest. I’m also rather fond of Jo Walton’s Tooth and Claw.

  6. December 31, 2015 1:48 pm

    Oh! What’d you think of Star Wars? I know that’s not what this post is about but I am just curious! (I loved Uprooted too.)

    • January 1, 2016 8:25 am

      I have seen every Star Wars movie in the theater as soon as it came out and loved it pretty much uncritically, including the prequel movies. (I was 17 when the first Star Wars came out.) When the original three were re-done in anticipation of the prequels, we took 3-year-old Walker and 6-year-old Eleanor to Columbus to see them on the big screen, and so they are big fans of the movies too, although somewhat more critical of the prequels, as the younger generation tends to be.
      One of our first Halloweens in Ohio, I did my hair and made a white dress to be Leia and Ron found a squirt gun “blaster” and dressed as Han.
      I was a little distressed to find that “my” son had gone to the dark side in this latest movie.
      On the day the new movie came out, though, Walker and Stephanie and Eleanor all dressed as Han.
      We went to London when Walker was 3-1/2, and he looked so much like the little boy who plays Anakin in the podracing prequel that people stopped us to exclaim over it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: